New Delhi – Lok Sabha MP Shashi Tharoor has asserted that India's pursuit of bilateral free trade agreements (FTAs) has more often led to widened trade deficits and weakened global value-chain integration than to significant export growth. Tharoor, who chairs the Standing Committee on External Affairs, made these observations in a recent opinion piece, emphasizing the critical need for simultaneous industrial and business reforms.
India's Worsening Trade Deficits
Tharoor highlighted alarming trade data from 2012 to 2025, noting a substantial increase in India's trade deficit with ASEAN, which surged from $10.4 billion to $51.2 billion. During the same period, India's share in the total import baskets of its major FTA partners stagnated or even declined.
- India's share of ASEAN's import market fell from 3.42% to 1.71%.
- In Singapore, it shrank from 2.27% to 1.71%.
- In South Korea, it dipped from 1.33% to 1.02%.
Furthermore, India's trade-related value-chain integration, measured as a percentage of gross trade, decreased from 37.13% to 34.38% over these years. This weakening was observed across key hubs like South Korea, Japan, Indonesia, Thailand, Vietnam, and Cambodia, with gains seen only in isolated cases such as Malaysia, Singapore, and the Philippines.
The Need for Domestic Reforms Alongside FTAs
While expressing support for trade diplomacy and a move away from protectionism, Tharoor cautioned that FTAs, though useful for securing critical raw materials, expanding service exports, and building strategic alignments, carry risks if not coupled with robust domestic policies. He warned that signing trade agreements without strengthening domestic manufacturing, logistics, infrastructure, regulatory processes, and reducing the cost of doing business creates an asymmetric market access environment.
"The hard truth is that zero-tariff market access for India still means that our exports have to compete with exports from other countries that may have similarly low levels of tariffs for their products," Tharoor wrote.
Such an imbalance, he argued, disproportionately favors foreign imports over Indian exports, undermining the potential benefits of these agreements. He also touched upon concerns regarding corruption, stating, "And we must end the appalling situation that leads every businessman I have met in the last few months to lament that corruption has never been worse."
A Message to Minister Piyush Goyal
Concluding his remarks, Tharoor directed a pointed question to Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal, urging him to consider his dual responsibilities. "Even as I applaud the new pacts we are so enthusiastically signing, I would like to offer a friendly word to Piyush Goyal: you have a double-barrelled responsibility; you are minister of both commerce and industry. Are you being consumed by the first half of your portfolio while neglecting the second?"
Tharoor's critique underscores the importance of a holistic approach to trade policy, where market liberalization is complemented by strategic domestic reforms to ensure sustainable economic growth and competitive advantage for India.