A significant trade dispute has emerged between India and the UK, marking the first major hurdle for the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) which came into effect in July. At the heart of the disagreement is the tariff classification of bulk Scotch whisky imports, leading to a logjam that impacts major alcoholic beverage manufacturers.
Under the India-UK CETA, packaged Scotch whisky, whether in containers up to 2 litres or exceeding 2 litres, is meant to attract a reduced tariff rate of 75%, down from the previous 150% duty. The industry anticipated that bulk Scotch whisky, imported in larger containers for blending and manufacturing within India, would also benefit from this concessional rate.
Customs Classification Sparks Controversy
However, the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI) has taken a different stance. Customs authorities are reportedly reclassifying these bulk imports not as whisky, but as “compound alcoholic preparations” under the tariff line “food preparations not elsewhere specified or included.” This reclassification would subject the imports to the higher pre-CETA duty rate of 150%.
Industry experts emphasize that this is fundamentally a classification issue, not a move to generate additional revenue. Karthik Iyer, Partner – Indirect Tax, Tax & Regulatory Advisory, BDO India, noted that the controversy stems from how the India-UK trade agreement’s provisions are being implemented regarding customs classifications.
Impact on Industry and Resolution Efforts
Thousands of litres of bulk Scotch whisky are currently held at Indian ports, disrupting supply chains for major players like Pernod Ricard, Diageo, and Bacardi, who rely on these imports for their blended whisky products in India's substantial liquor market. This dispute could have significant working capital and compliance implications for the entire alcoholic beverage industry.
Commerce Secretary Rajesh Agrawal has affirmed India's commitment to the trade deal, stating that efforts are actively underway to resolve the issue swiftly. Both Indian and UK officials are engaged in discussions to address this classification dilemma, aiming to provide clarity and stability for investors and the industry.