Search

Cookies

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you accept our use of cookies.

Business

Venu Srinivasan's Counsel Rejects Lakshmi Venu's TVS Asset Claim as 'Change of Mind'

· · 3 min read

Senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, representing Venu Srinivasan, dismisses Lakshmi Venu's challenge to the TVS family asset division. He argues previous settlements from 2017, 2020, and 2024 are binding and cannot be reopened due to "retrospective dissatisfaction."

TVS Family Asset Dispute: Counsel Counters Lakshmi Venu's Challenge

The ongoing TVS family asset dispute has seen a strong rebuttal from Venu Srinivasan's lead counsel, senior Supreme Court advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi. Singhvi has categorically dismissed Lakshmi Venu's recent challenge to the family's asset division, characterizing it as "nothing but a change of mind" on her part.

Lakshmi Venu had served a partition notice on her father, Venu Srinivasan, seeking an equal share of the family's extensive assets, a claim supported by her mother, Mallika Srinivasan. However, Singhvi contends that Lakshmi and Mallika Srinivasan cannot arbitrarily reopen settlements that were signed and agreed upon years ago, simply because they now perceive the distribution as unfair.

Previous Agreements Deemed Final and Binding

Singhvi emphasized that the dispute fundamentally stems from a retrospective dissatisfaction with agreements formalized in 2017, 2020, and 2024. He stated, "We're all talking of very high-powered, empowered persons is nothing but a change of mind which is being camouflaged and couched in different ways."

He challenged the timing of the claims, particularly regarding gender discrimination, arguing that such issues are being raised long after the family had reached consensus on asset division. "You cannot say that when I signed, it was fair, but today, 10 years later, I believe it's not equitable," Singhvi asserted, questioning the rationale behind accepting the agreements initially if they were deemed unfair.

The 2017 Partition and Subsequent Settlements

A crucial point of contention is the written partition agreement from 2017, which Singhvi described as final and binding. This settlement, he noted, covered both ancestral and personally owned assets. He highlighted the legal weight of a signed, written partition, stating, "As you know in law, you can even have an oral partition. But this is signed and in writing. It says that this is final and binding and nobody shall challenge in any manner."

The counsel further elaborated on the wider TVS family settlement in 2020, where Venu Srinivasan reportedly paid nearly ₹2,000 crore to acquire control of the automobile business. Singhvi revealed that Mallika Srinivasan and Lakshmi Venu declined to contribute to this substantial payment, leaving Venu and Sudarshan Venu to bear the financial obligation. This arrangement, he added, was reinforced by a 2024 agreement that included reciprocal non-compete provisions.

Lakshmi's Beneficiary Status and Future Outlook

Addressing suggestions that Lakshmi Venu had been excluded from family business interests, Singhvi pointed out that the VS Trust, which controls shares in Sundaram-Clayton, lists Lakshmi's son as its primary beneficiary. "Now it is true that technically Clayton doesn't go to Lakshmi. But all the shares are for the benefit of her son," he clarified. He also mentioned an understanding that the tractor business, currently associated with Mallika Srinivasan, is intended for Lakshmi's side, while the automobile business is earmarked for Sudarshan.

Singhvi confirmed that both ownership and management responsibilities were explicitly addressed in the 2017 and 2020 agreements. When questioned about the emergence of the dispute despite these prior agreements, Singhvi placed the onus on the mother and daughter. "They sent me the legal notice. I didn't send them a legal notice. They signed the documents. Nobody held a gun to their head to sign it," he stated.

A response to Lakshmi Venu's partition notice is expected shortly. Singhvi has rejected the idea of a fresh independent valuation of family assets, arguing it would undermine the finality of existing agreements. He warned that if legal notices continue, the dispute appears destined for litigation.

Related