Search

Cookies

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you accept our use of cookies.

Business

Surjit Bhalla Criticizes India's Trade Deal Failures Amid AI Investment Debate

· · 3 min read

Economist Surjit Bhalla has criticized India's stalled trade agreements with the UK and US, calling for focus on economic basics before AI ambitions. His remarks join a debate between Uday Kotak and Mohandas Pai on Indian deep tech investment.

Economist Surjit Bhalla has questioned India's approach to international trade agreements, particularly with the United States and the United Kingdom. His comments, made on November 19, 2026, come amidst a broader discussion among prominent Indian business leaders regarding the nation's economic priorities and investment in emerging technologies like artificial intelligence (AI).

Bhalla argued that India needs to address fundamental economic issues, including its inability to finalize crucial trade deals, before aspiring to leadership in advanced AI. Taking to X (formerly Twitter), he expressed frustration:

"And why is it that we cannot even get a trade deal right - none with the US and now one with UK in jeopardy - all for a few pennies of revenue for the government? Let us explain the basics first before getting into AI."

India-UK Trade Deal Hits Snag Over Scotch Whisky Duties

The India-UK free trade agreement, which officially commenced in July 2026, has encountered a significant dispute over customs duties on Scotch whisky imports. Despite agreed-upon tariff concessions that saw duties on eligible Scotch whisky reduced from 150% to 75%, British exporters have reported that Indian customs authorities are seeking higher duties on certain bulk shipments.

A UK government spokesperson confirmed on Wednesday that ministers are actively engaging with India to resolve the issue, aiming to ensure British businesses receive the full tariff benefits outlined in the pact.

US-India Bilateral Trade Talks Continue

Meanwhile, negotiations for a bilateral trade agreement between India and the United States are ongoing. Commerce Secretary Rajesh Agrawal stated on Wednesday that discussions are nearing completion, though the final signing awaits Washington's new tariff framework.

The Anthropic Valuation Debate

Bhalla's criticism emerged as a debate unfolded between Kotak Mahindra Bank founder Uday Kotak and Aarin Capital Chairman Mohandas Pai. The discussion was sparked by the staggering $1.5 trillion valuation of Anthropic, an AI company behind the Claude chatbot, which went public on November 18, 2026.

Uday Kotak highlighted Anthropic's rapid ascent, questioning whether Indian businesses are undervalued or lagging in the race for emerging technologies.

"Anthropic, an AI company known for Claude, listed at a valuation of $1.5 trillion. It did not exist till ~ 5 years ago. This is more than the combined market cap of the top 10 Indian companies. Are we undervalued, or do we need to catch up in the new world? Or both?" Kotak posted on X.

Mohandas Pai, however, dismissed the comparison as "silly," asserting that market disruptions naturally create new companies with immense valuations. Pai then challenged Kotak directly, asking why India's financial sector, including leading bankers, isn't investing more aggressively in innovation and deep tech to foster an environment for Indian "Anthropics" to emerge.

The exchange underscores a growing tension between focusing on fundamental economic stability and pursuing ambitious technological advancements within India's business landscape.

Related